removed by mod
basically loudly and excitedly declaring that you have no idea what’s going on.
Be specific. What’s wrong with my proposal?
The first problem is that it’s ethnic cleansing. The second is that Israel would never agree to give up any of the West Bank, the third is that Egypt would not agree to take the Palestinians(they’ve been asked before, including by Biden.)
removed by mod
Israel would give up the West Bank for much more land in the Sinai.
No they wouldn’t
Israel would have the potential to become a much more populous and powerful country.
They already have ten percent of their population in West Bank. They’re not giving it up.
Egypt would not be taking in Palestinians. Egypt would simply own the land they are in.
That’s Egypt taking Palestinians.
Egypt could give them the land.
Yeah, but they won’t. And Israel wouldn’t recognize it anyway
And it’s all still ethnic cleansing.
Beyond the ethnic cleansing issues everyone already presented:
- How are you calculating the ‘value of the land’?
- Who deternimes the value and where the new borders are to be drawn?
- Do family estates get prorated for sentimental and historical value?
- What is the conversion rate of coastline and maritime claims to arable land?
- Does Israel get to keep the value of settlements that it already holds either “legally” (per Israeli law) or illegally?
- Why would Israeli settlers in illegal settlements vacate, and (perhaps more to the point) why would the Israeli state stop backing them when they decided not to leave?
- Why would Egypt give up control of an excellent defensive border region to a hostile neighbor for a noncontiguous state that would likely be re-occupied by said state before the treaty ink is dry?
removed by mod
What you’re describing is ethnic cleansing.
removed by mod
That’s still, literally, ethnic cleansing
removed by mod
Forcibly resettling a population is ethnic cleansing
Tell me, what was Hitler’s plan with the Jews during WWII other than the holocaust? He wanted to send them to Argentina and Madagascar
removed by mod
He wanted to exterminate them
It’s a historically undesputed fact that Hitler first planned to expel them from Europe, and only moved onto extermination when it became clear he wouldn’t be able to.
Palestinians in Gaza would have to move.
That’s ethnic cleansing.
removed by mod
Because it’s ethnic cleansing.
Part of the issue here is that it would mean moving when people don’t want to move. They want to be where they originated from.
Also @BrainInABox@lemmy.ml is a troll that looks to purity test and demotivate anything that would help Palestinians. I might go as far as to say they want the genocide to go on as they keep talking trash on anything that could be pragmatic in helping Palestine. Difficult to say as they won’t answer what their proposed plan is or why they keep purity testing everything. Just in case you want to have a productive conversation they are not the person to do so with.
Please point to where I have trolled. You’ve followed me across multiple instances but still have not been able to do it.
Dude why are you trying to make ethnic cleansing work
removed by mod
Forcibly expelling an entire population is ethnic cleansing
Imagine if we created a state for jews, in fucking antartica and we pointed our guns at all the jews in the world and told them they have to go there or they’re not citizens, that’s ethnic cleansing
removed by mod
deleted by creator
removed by mod
would have to move
yeah, that’s ethnic cleansing
